Skip to main content

Goliaths, Davids, and the Rules of War

 

He thought it would be over in three days. Swoop in, decapitate the government, install a new one, piece of cake. Instead it’s turned into an extended exercise in barbarity, targeting civilian populations, destroying infrastructure, and ruining multiple economies, with no apparent strategy or purpose beyond stroking a sociopath’s ego.

Are we talking about Trump or Putin here? Iran or Ukraine? Hard to tell from just that paragraph. The similarities are as striking as the differences, the big difference being that Iran is just getting started, while Ukraine is a more mature catastrophe, four years in the making. Another difference is that Ukraine’s impact on the world economy after four years will prove to be a mere fraction of Iran’s after a few months.

But Ukraine has been the harbinger of a new kind of war, which is now ready for prime time. Asymmetric war. Goliath-versus-David war. Total offense versus shrewd defense. Fertile ground for atrocities and war crimes of every sort.

The Goliaths apply overwhelming force, mostly from the air, wreaking maximum destruction on the population. They confuse destruction with victory, and they never seem to learn what militaries have known since before the Vietnam War: that for all the damage it inflicts, bombing alone cannot overthrow regimes or subdue populations. What it does do is piss off the people whose towns are being bombed, and make them hate you for generations.

The Davids, on the other hand, are invariably outgunned, out-spent, and generally out-resourced. They’re forced to get by on tactical ingenuity, cheap technology, the threat of imminent extinction, and a shared primal rage at the wanton molestation of their homes.

Ukraine was where we in the pampered West first learned that civilians and infrastructure can be fair game for missiles, drones, and artillery. It’s where we first grasped that whole cities, like Mariupol, could be reduced to rubble, and that hellish privation and death could spread across thousands of people at a time.

This is not new at all if you live in Syria or Chechnya, places where Putin first tried out obliteration as a policy initiative. Nor is it new in Gaza, where Israel has created a humanitarian disaster, and where an under-reported ecological emergency is literally rising from the rubble of destroyed buildings, releasing toxic chemicals into the air, water, and earth. Manmade calamities come in many forms.

We might long for the days when the Geneva Conventions actually held some sway among nations, even ours — though our own record has been sketchier than we’d like to admit. We roll our eyes when the subject comes up, knowing full well that international accountability for Trump, Putin, or any of their stooges will always be a long shot.

But while there is something surreal about the idea of having rules for something as innately barbaric as war, there has been some comfort — at least in the past — in knowing there were lines that have generally been seen as too catastrophic to cross. Which is why it is so distressing to see those lines being crossed now, on a regular basis.

In the Middle East, there has long been an informal but dead-serious agreement among the various states that thou shalt not attack either petroleum facilities or desalination plants. It is obvious to all parties that the cycle of retaliation and escalation would be mutually suicidal.

And yet, already various oil production installations have come under attack, with Iranian missiles and drones inflicting damage in most of the neighboring petro-states.

But while shutting down oil production threatens livelihoods, shutting down desalination is an immediate threat to lives. In a region where 56 desalination plants account for 90 percent of desalinated water — and where desalinated water accounts for 70 percent of the water in Saudi Arabia, 90 percent in Kuwait, 80 in Israel, and so on — figure 100 million people could lose access to dependable drinking water.

I am posting this piece on Tuesday, the day Trump has given as a deadline to “Open the Fuckin' Strait, you crazy bastards, or you'll be living in Hell.” He’s threatened to attack Iranian bridges and oil facilities. He didn’t mention desalination plants, but it could’ve slipped his mind, as much about this war tends to do. While it would be absurd to take him at his word, that doesn’t mean he won’t be in the mood to blow stuff up.

As bad ideas go, this would be one of the all-time greats. First of all, Iran is far better equipped to weather a water crisis than any of the other Middle Eastern states, including Israel. But even if looked at from a purely selfish, American national security perspective, there are excellent reasons why we don’t want 100 million people angry at us.

As a country, we have long lived under the illusion that two oceans give us distance from the world’s biggest trouble spots, and that we are therefore immune to any meaningful blowback from strife in other regions. This is delusional, and it assumes that we wouldn’t be stupid enough to poke a major hornet’s nest like Iran, and think we wouldn’t get stung.

Of course, a lot of the blowback will be economic, and wholly Trump-inflicted. By the midterms, we’ll be lucky if we have gas in our cars and food on our table.

But we’ll also be lucky if the carnage we’ve inflicted on others isn’t ultimately inflicted on us. Iranian drones don’t have the range to reach our shores, but what’s to stop Iranian proxies launching them from Cuba or Canada or Mexico, or even building them right here. They’re small, they’re cheap to make, and they can kill a lot of people. And that’s just one sort of threat.

This is happening just as the Trump regime has, with malice aforethought, weakened our ability to deal with such blowback. They’ve eviscerated the State Department, so that credible diplomacy is no longer possible, even with our allies. They’re purging the military, determined to make it exclusively male, white, Christian, and stupid. They’ve crippled the intelligence community, including national cyber defense, just as we’re facing off against one of the most sophisticated cyber-warfare states in the world. When the wifi goes down, we’ll know the war has reached us.

So here we are. Two wars, started by two Goliaths. Neither makes sense. Neither shows any sign of letting up. Neither shows any respect for human life.

We can argue that the rules of war are silly, that treaties aren’t worth the paper they’re written on, that might makes right. But we’d be missing the point, which is that the rules, whatever their pros or cons, are not being followed.

And while most of us don’t like to think of ourselves as Goliath, we’re the ones not following them.

 

Comments

  1. Well said.Three thoughts. One, monolithic thinking gets Neanderthal policy. Two, one maniac made everything bad for everyone everywhere all at the same time. Third, pilots and missile officers firing on civilian targets are committing war crimes (in addition to Trump) and are authorized by the US Military Code of Justice to refuse these illegal orders.

    ReplyDelete
  2. If you are right, Lefty, after tonight, we will be watching the end of rope-a-dope. This will be our last round before Iran comes out swinging. What can we expect? The whole playbook: cyber attacks, suicide bombings, more hidden missiles, and drones...lots of them.

    Steve Keen has suggested that they might even have a plan to disable Israel's nukes. They've been planning for this as long as Israel and way longer than us.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Making Sense — Or Not — of an Electoral Smackdown

I waited all night for bad news. I was Charlie Brown, certain that Lucy would yank the football away at the last second. Last Tuesday is still too big to grasp at this time, so I’m going to string together a few random thoughts, none of which would add up to a full essay. I’ll try to focus on things I’m not seeing much of in the media. The pundits are arguing about whether this epic smackdown was about the Iran war, which it was. Or about gas prices, which it also was. Or about tariffs, healthcare, inflation, ICE, or massive corruption. And yes, the list is long. But they’re all looking at the trees. The forest was Donald Trump. Or should I say the forest fire? He was the only thing on the ballot, a monster loose upon the land. Tuesday was a primal scream, ten years in the making, a scream rising from the monster’s victims, which all of us are. Tuesday was pure rage at the gall of this deranged narcissist for taking a flawed but functional country and deliberately wrecking it...

Abdul El-Sayed Plays MAGA Bingo with Mike Rogers

   If it had been a prize fight, they’d have stopped it in the early rounds. The final Michigan Senate debate between Abdul El-Sayed and Mike Rogers was hardly the mano-a-mano blood sport the press would have you believe, but plenty of mud — or a mud-like substance — was slung, all from one side of the aisle. It’s well  worth watching . Rogers tried mightily to get people with weak minds to see El-Sayed as a terrorist monster bent on jihad from the Senate floor. Which, sad to say, is a lie that lands easily in certain Michigan circles. There are still, for instance, a shocking number of misguided Jews who insist on feeling threatened by him, and for no rational reason. Let’s now stipulate that the Muslim Brotherhood is not exactly top-of-mind for most Michiganders, but it’s all Rogers had to work with. His was not an easy hand to play, especially with the Trump stink wafting off him, but he played it badly nonetheless. He was flustered, ill-informed, ...

Suppose We Do Win Both House and Senate. Then What?

   My friend in Ontario is frustrated, as I can well imagine. As Trump continues to drive our country over a cliff — and drag his country over with it — he has asked me just what difference a blue takeover of Congress might actually make. A good question, in and of itself. But then he asks, “ Even if there is a change in Congress, what could that do if Trump goes around them anyway?” My answer to both was as glib as it was unhelpful: Who knows, I said, but we need to flip Congress anyway. Even if Democrats can capture both House and Senate, their ability to push back will be limited. They’ll be able to prevent things — crazy new laws, egregious appointments, corrupt funding — and that’s not nothing. But prevention isn’t cure, and given Trump’s personal chokehold on the world, a lot of curing will be desperately needed. Over the next two years the headwinds will be fierce. Even a strongly Democratic Congress will have little more than a larger platform fo...