Skip to main content

Raise Your Hand if You’re Fed Up with Mainstream News

I am not the first to notice that, just in the past week, there’s been a crescendo of disgust at the nakedly disingenuous behavior of the mainstream press.

Some of my more politically-astute sources have been throwing up their hands at the apparent unwillingness of the press — purportedly a pillar of democracy — to protect us from the slow-motion insurrection being mounted, in real time, by right-wing vandals.

There’s plenty to be disgusted with:

There’s the endless both-siderism, most obviously the obsessive weighing of Joe Biden’s age against Trump’s four criminal indictments, as if to ask which is worse.

There’s the accumulation of Democrats-in-disarray stories that appear almost daily, in which “insiders” express panic at the Democratic party’s stubborn unwillingness to give credence to open seditionists and nihilistic buffoons.

There are the stories about the economy, where any good news — of which there’s been plenty — must be tempered by dire warnings from “experts” about the imminent recession, which has been imminent for two years now, ever since Biden took office, which is not a coincidence.

More recently, there’s the deification of Rupert Murdoch, even now being hailed in retirement as a “media visionary” — which he surely is, though as visions go, the sabotage of liberal democracy is not one I’d want to be known for.

But for many, the last straw was Kristen Welker’s appalling pander to Trump on her debut as host of Meet The Press. A bad idea gone horribly wrong, you can’t help but wonder what NBC was thinking. It’s not like there wasn’t a precedent for disaster — CNN is still reeling from its grotesquely stupid Trump town hall back in May.

But the very idea that a major TV network would air a world-class serial liar —and leave a blizzard of world-class lies unchallenged — underscores just how untrustworthy our trusted news sources have become.

I’ve virtually given up on television news, and again I’m not alone. Even MSNBC, once a comforting presence in a hostile world, has taken on the conservative tinge of its parent companies, NBC and Comcast. It has devolved into a cavalcade of has-been pundits, too many of whom started out as Republicans, and too few of whom have anything meaningful to say.

Mostly, it seems to be MSNBC’s job, as a company, to make sure their viewers stay petrified of Trump and skeptical of Biden. This is quite clearly a corporate strategy, and the likes of Rachel Maddow and Lawrence O’Donnell are loudly silent about it.

But the co-opting of MSNBC is just the tip of the iceberg. Among most of the mainstream media, the nation’s headlong slide into fascist theocracy is still not a subject for polite conversation.

So there is much to hate in the way The New York Times, The Washington Post, CNN, and the other “major” news outlets have basically abandoned their journalistic principles in the interest of manufactured controversy.

Claiming to seek “balance,” “fairness,” and “objectivity,” they’ll cynically make a two-sided conflict out of anything, even if it means amplifying — and therefore legitimizing — right-wing propaganda.

To see how this works, look no further than the “Joe Biden is too old” narrative.

This particular mind-virus was concocted by right-wing media — Fox, Breitbart, Newsmax, the usual suspects — who have long been desperate to slime Joe Biden with anything they can make stick.

To them, Biden is infuriatingly bland. Nothing about him offers the slightest whiff of scandal or bad faith. With so little to work with, they make stuff up — Hunter’s laptop, House investigations, immigrant invasions, bogus impeachment, government shutdown — but nothing gets much traction. They relentlessly paint Biden as a ghoulish criminal mastermind who feasts on dead babies, which plays well with their zombie base, but poorly with real humans.

But the “Biden’s age” story is different. It’s based on objective reality, a rare thing in their world. Biden is indeed old, after all. And while it isn’t much to work with, propagandistically speaking, they’ll flog it anyway. They’ve done much more with much less in the past — think Hillary’s emails.

So they cook up the “argument” that Biden is a doddering, senile old fool who drools in his oatmeal, and is obviously just pretending to be a ghoulish criminal mastermind who feasts on dead babies. Their audience easily accommodates both narratives.

But one of the things right-wing media is distressingly good at is spreading its slime beyond its immediate audience of nitwits and nutjobs. The mainstream press is fully complicit in this, whether they acknowledge it or not.

The media and social media ecospheres are constantly being seeded with dishonest stories looking for “legs.” These slimy stories bubble up from the ooze and ripple outward, lapping against the mainstream, which is always on the lookout for Democrats-in-disarray stories.

Inevitably, the slime sloshes onto Twitter and Facebook, where it gets noticed even by Democrats, who always need things about Biden to worry about. It bubbles up to the Sunday talk shows, where the apparent need to attack, or defend, Biden’s age gives the whole topic far more oxygen than it deserves.

By the time it bubbles up to CNN — or to any other outlet that normalizes Republican propaganda — Biden’s age is now solemnly proclaimed an “issue,” in the presidential race, something “everyone’s talking about.”

But it’s not finished bubbling. Now we’re seeing the “serious” columns on the op-ed pages of the Times and WaPo, each bringing sober and reasoned perspectives to the “controversy.” And OMG, Joe Scarborough is very concerned, Mika too.

So what started as a small piece of actuarial reality is now a nationwide virus, spreading mind to mind, and being amplified by supposedly trustworthy media.

This “issue” will keep bubbling through the next election. It will be accompanied by none-too-subtle racism and misogyny directed at the black woman who’s a mere “heartbeat away” from the presidency. And now that it’s gone mainstream, Biden’s age will be fair game for any clown to weigh in on. At the expense of real issues.

We need better from the press. These are treacherous times, and the people who are supposed to be pointing out the treachery think it’s good business to pretend it’s not there.

There are indeed two sides here — democracy or fascism — and the press needs to choose one. If anything, it would be nice to know where we stand.


  1. I sometimes wonder what Walter Cronkite would say were he alive to see what's happening to the media. Real investigative reporting seems to be too expensive or inconvenient these days. They used to put up an "opinion" or "editorial" banner when real news wasn't being offered. Now, if they still did that, they could just leave it up.

  2. We need one member of the MSM to have the guts to ask Trump, to his face, "Why do you lie about everything all the time?"

    1. I don't imagine they'd waste their time. Lying liars lie about lying too.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Warning: Red States may be Hazardous to your Health

In late September, a Nebraska woman was sentenced to two years in prison for helping her daughter obtain abortion pills. The case was less about abortion than about some bizarre behavior regarding the burial of the fetal remains, but this is still appalling on any number of levels. Even so, that’s not what piqued my interest. Rather, I was drawn to one curious footnote to the story, and I’ve heard nothing about it since. Apparently, the judge in the case had ordered the woman to undergo a psychological evaluation prior to sentencing. Presumably, the results might have helped to mitigate her sentence. Which sounds reasonable, perhaps even routine. But that evaluation never happened. It was, strangely, “cancelled due to lack of funding.” Huh? A person whose future may have hinged on that evaluation was denied it because the state couldn’t afford it? How underfunded are we talking? How many other people moving through the Nebraska judicial system haven’t rece

The Media Wakes Up and Smells the Fascism

  A funny thing happened on the way to the 2024 horserace. The mainstream media brought Hitler into the conversation. Trump gave them no choice. He kept amping up his rants in terms that were so explicitly Nazi, so lifted — practically verbatim — from Hitler’s speeches, that it was hard for them to keep ignoring what they’ve willfully ignored for so long. When Trump used the word ‘vermin’ in his Veteran’s Day speech , he was taking a whole chapter from the fascism playbook. Whether he knew it or not. Dehumanization — the art of equating human beings with insects — is a classic stochastic terrorism technique, beloved of dictators the world over. In Rwanda in the nineties, the Hutu tribe openly called its rival Tutsis “cockroaches” on the radio, inciting its members to exterminate them with machetes, which they did. We’ll probably never know who actually wrote the Vermin speech — Stephen Miller or Steve Bannon are likely suspects — but we can be sure it wasn’t T

Things Have Been Too Cheap for Too Long

  Once upon a time, gasoline cost roughly 35 cents a gallon. That halcyon era came to an abrupt halt during the Carter administration, when oil-rich Arab states severely constricted our petroleum supply, causing hours-long lines at the gas pump that are still fresh in the memory of anyone who was there. When the dust cleared, gas was four times more expensive, and now we count ourselves lucky if it’s only ten times that long-ago price. But we did get over it, more or less. We learned to live with it. Around that time, some pundit I can’t remember said something that has stuck with me ever since. To paraphrase, “This country was built on cheap energy and cheap labor, and we’re running out of both.” It stuck with me because it’s even truer now than it was then. This despite the best efforts of corporate interests — and their Republican flunkies in government — to do all they can to keep both energy and labor as cheap as possible. For several decades, they made